Should there be tags for the language used in a question?
Obviously, this would enable good filtering.
Upvote this question if you are in favour of:
Each question should have a tag lang:en or lang:de or lang:en-de
1
-
This suggestion might make language tagging superfluous: Translating posts as a "community norm" – Pekka May 24 '11 at 22:04
Add a comment
|
This would be a meta tag and meta tags are explicitly discouraged:
The reason meta-tags are a problem is that they do not describe the content of the question. They describe how or why the question is being asked. You know a meta tag when you see it because meta tags don't make any sense unless they are paired with other tags. Inexperienced users often don't realize this and they start using those tags by themselves. It starts breaking the tagging system.
This isn't an obvious problem at first, but this was a big problem on other sites before we learned how to deal with them… by banning them outright.
Please don't repeat our mistakes of the past. No english and no german tags, please.
I'm in favor of language tags for minor languages.
Spamming every question with english or german tags will be largely redundant, but if this site evolves to accept questions about many different languages in relation to German, language specific tags should be useful.
As a rule, I'd say that german tags are useless, since every question should be about German on this site. english is the lingua franca and would be equally redundant in most cases. Any other language used should be tagged.
See: Wie kann man 気持ちいい am besten auf Deutsch ausdrücken? and Should translation questions be bounded to German-English?.
