5

Not too long ago a user asked for the differeces between four similar words. The question was answered three times within two days with relatively good answers, albeit none accepted.

A further two days later, he realised, that there is another similar word and decided to extend the question to include that fifth word.

I commented saying that his question was pretty old, had gotten answers and was probably out of sight for most people now. I also felt that this turned his question into a ‘moving target’ aka hard to bullseye with an answer. I haven’t, however, found a general policy on the topic so far.

  • Should this kind of late extensions be allowed?

    • If not, how should a user who realises that their question didn’t include all the related terms and wants to add more act? Ask a new question with reference to the old one?

    • Also if not, what should we do to askers that do that? Rollback and add a comment? Just comment?

2
  • 1
    Repeated extensions to questions are known as "chameleon questions" in the SO slang – Vogel612 May 14 '15 at 14:07
  • However the example we have here not really qualifies as such a chameleon question as it was in above meta post. – Takkat May 14 '15 at 18:26
2

Nobody’s bothering to answer, so I’ll post my thoughts as an answer and see if it gets any votes.

  • Additions to questions are, of course, reasonable and allowed if posted within the first few hours, ideally before any answers have been given.

  • If there are no answers, late additions can still be allowed, as it shifts the question back up in the active questions tab.

  • If there are already answers, late additions should not be allowed and the question edited back to its original form. The asker should be asked to create a new question referencing back to the old one instead. The edit should be explained in a comment, ideally pointing to this meta post.

1
  • I totally agree (and upvoted your answer). Sorry, I visit the meta-board rarely, maybe once per month or even rarer. – Hubert Schölnast May 29 '15 at 7:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .